This post contains affiliate links . Read full disclosure statement here .
While many people consider that sure plants and essential crude can repel mosquitoes and forestall bites , the research distinguish a different story . It turn out that planting a few garden favorites or lighting candles wo n’t in effect keep those pesky germ away .
If you enjoy seeing what the science says about popular garden topic , also seePopular Garden Myths We ’ve All Fallen For .
Mosquitoes in the garden
Which Mosquito Repellents Really Work?
It ’s the prison term of year where mosquitoes are a trouble for some of us so I cogitate it would be interesting to see what the research says about various alternative repellents .
Keep in mind that I am divvy up what the enquiry shows . This is not advice for what to use . It is just a look at whether researchers have been able to substantiate any of the popularanecdotalclaims about various “ mosquito - repelling ” plant and other DIY repellents .
Small flying insects• 3,500 species• maturation : egg to adult in 5 to 40 days• Trivia : Antarctica and Iceland do not have mosquitoes• Harm : Cause more deaths than any other fauna group
Mosquitoes in the garden
How Good is Good Enough?
Before we dive in to some specific remedies , let ’s call back about the big question .
How effective does something have to be to be good enough ?
There are some alternate repellents that cut down mosquito bites by 40 % .
And , at first , that sounds good . We ’ve probably all bought products like this .
But with mosquitoes , what does that mean ?
or else of getting eaten live , we ’ll only get 60 % eat live ?
This may sound okay if you live somewhere where mosquito are considered an vexation and not much more .
But , if you are allergic to bite like I am or see yourself somewhere mosquitoes spread deadly disease like malaria or West Nile virus , getting any bites is potentially much more serious .
Along with circumscribed efficaciousness , some alternative repellent may only influence for a very limited clock time : 5 , 10 , or perhaps 30 minutes . After that , it ’s open time of year .
So how effective do we need these things to be to recommend them ?
Contents
Mosquito Repellents: Which Ones Work?
Essential Oils
Many of the essence oils do n’t work at all , some work for a very short time , and a few are okay , but that ’s about it .
Citronella , extracted from the works citronella grass ( Cymbopogon nardus ) , is perhaps the most popular essential oil color associated with repelling mosquitoes .
And , while some may bank by it , the effectiveness is limited .
In a 2018 reassessment of tests for repelling mosquitoes , Consumer Reports say :
“ We advise cut most products made with natural plant oils , such as those with citronella , lemongrass oil , cedar vegetable oil , and other ingredients . They did not perform well in our tests . ”
The only oil colour with research to back it up isoil of stinker eucalyptus(PMD)—called Citriodiol in the UK , which you may have noticed in some commercial repellents in recent years .
And , keep in mind as you read this — if something can repel some mosquitoes , even temporarily , where exactly do you mean they ’ll go ? We want them far enough from us not to bite us , but , in reality , a repellent might just temporarily send them a groundwork or so away . And then what ?
Related : The Problem With acetum as a Weed Killer
Candles
For some multitude , a summertime evening on the patio is not consummate withoutmosquito - repelling candlesburning in hopes of keeping those flying origin - suckers at true laurel .
But are the candles really reducing the bites ?
Research from Science cartridge ( 2017 ) say :
“ Citronella candles are great for setting a mood , but they ’re not so great for the very affair they ’re advertise to do : push back mosquito . ”
And logically , if mosquitoes are present , and an item repels them , how far by are they really going to go ? Far enough to protect us bystanders from bites ?
A better option may be to keep a fan blowing so the mosquitoes never reach you .
touch on : Breaking the Eggshell Myth in Gardening
Traps & Zappers
gob that come-on mosquitoes have n’t get along well in tests , partly because , if they do attract mosquitoes , not all of them end up in the trap .
In one discipline , some pop traps actually increase the number of pungency people start .
Zappers , sonic devices , and wristbands ? None of them have worthwhile solvent . And , they do n’t single out — so other beneficial creatures can get zapped as well .
One wearable that did got in force result : Off makes a time - on repellent with a built - in rooter , and those did OK . The force of the blow air is perhaps more helpful than anything else .
Eating Allium sativum ? take B1 supplement ? Nope .
associate : Why Epsom Salt is Not Good For Your Garden ( or the Environment )
Plants
What about those plant that are hypothesise to keep mosquitoes away ?
I ’ve interpret lemongrass , lemon balm , lavender , lemon thyme , catnip , basil , rosemary , garlic , marigold , and citrosa all advise and article claim their effectiveness are shared like dotty online .
But no , despite all the enthusiasm and wishful thinking , they are not the sorcerous mosquito repellent we dream of .
And even if they could repel a mosquito , how will that serve us ?
Do we really suppose lemon thyme is going to provide a 10 or 30 or 50 - animal foot mosquito - wicked force field of view that we can move freely in ? Not materialise .
At good it might think the mosquito just moves on to flit around something else nearby . Or us .
Citrosa plants ( genus Pelargonium ‘ citrosum’)—one of the most democratic recommendations — are specifically listed on Health Canada ’s “ mathematical product That Do n’t Protect Well ” list .
File this one under Popular Garden Folklore or Wishful Thinking .
connect : Expert Lavender grow Tips for Home Gardeners
Lotions & Spray
So where does this leave us ?
In gardening as in life there are not always great result to vulgar problem .
If preventing bites is a serious thing for you , these ingredients are shown to be most effective :
you could find all of them in sprays for topical purpose . pay off attention to the details : there are specific amounts needed to be effective and not all merchandise have sufficient amounts .
That enjoin , this is just a look at the research .
What you choose to trust and economic consumption is entirely up to you ( of trend ) .
Resources
Related Podcast Episodes
References / Read More
~Melissathe Empress of Dirt ♛
Empress of DirtEbooks
Reader ’s favorite tips and tutorials on various theme accumulate into handy downloadable ebooks .
